| Year Inducted | Name | Years at NWCC | Sport |
| 2006 | Robert Akins | 1973-75 | Football |
| Cecil Burford, Sr. | 1926-28 | Football, Basketball, Baseball | |
| Michael Joe Cannon | 1978-80 | Football | |
| Billy Rotenberry | 1960-62 | Track | |
| 2005 | Harry Adair | 1980-87 | Women's Basketball Coach |
| Catricia Howard | 1988-90 | Basketball | |
| Jack Peel | 1982-84 | Baseball | |
| Don Randolph | 1959-61 | Basketball | |
| Fred Thomas | 1992-94 | Football | |
| Lawrence "Bud" Young | 1973-present | Rodeo Coach | |
| 2004 | Donny Castle | 1979-present | Athletic Director, Baseball Coach |
| Eddie Halfacre | 1977-79 | Rodeo | |
| Arthur Kuntzman | 1960-61 | Football | |
| Eric Schwartz | 1982 | Football | |
| 2003 | Bobby Franklin | 1981-2005 | Football Coach |
| Cedric Matthews | 1990-92 | Basketball | |
| Tommy Simpson | 1956-58 | Basketball | |
| Paul Stroud, Jr. | 1960-61 | Football | |
| 2002 | James Randy Cook | 1976-77 | Football |
| Mike McClenton | 1988-89 | Football | |
| Gerald Perry | 1983-84 | Football | |
| Thomas Poff, Jr. | 1959-60 | Football | |
| Kenneth "Cat' Robbins | 1975-93 | Head Men's Basketball Coach | |
| 1997 | Cortez Kennedy | 1987-88 | Football |
| Mike Rowan | 1976-77 | Baseball, Football | |
| Henry Williams | 1981-82 | Football | |
| 1996 | Robert Whitwell | 1965 | Football |
| 1995 | Hollis Miller | 1971-72 | Basketball |
| Mark Robbins | 1982-84 | Football | |
| 1994 | Jim Miles | 1961-63 | Baseball, Basketball |
| Maurice Kelly | 1947-48 | Baseball, Basketball, Football | |
| 1993 | Bernard Blackwell | 1948-50 | Head Football Coach |
| John W. Clayton | 1951-53 | Basketball, Football | |
| Bobby Hogue | 1957-59 | Baseball, Football | |
| Kenny Hunt | 1959-60 | Baseball, Basketball | |
| Henry B. Koon | 1965-85 | President, Head Men's Basketball Coach | |
| 1992 | Darrel Arnold | 1953-55 | Baseball, Basketball, Football |
| Jamie Whitten Howell, Sr. | 1956-58 | Baseball, Basketball, Track | |
| Robert Eugene Proctor | 1951-53 | Baseball, Basketball, Football | |
| William C. Oakley | 1955-65 | Athletic Director, Basketball Coach, Football Coach | |
| Edwin Thomas | 1956-58 | Football | |
| 1991 | James Walden "John" Brewer | 1947-49 | Baseball, Football |
| James Carroll Johnson | 1929-32 | Baseball, Basketball, Football, Track | |
| Leslie Buford "Cy" Taylor | 1930-31 | Baseball, Basketball, Football, Track | |
| A.C. Williams, Jr. | 1935-37 | Baseball, Basketball, Football |