| Season | Player | Position | Honors |
| 2007 | Lauren Farris | Goalkeeper | NJCAA Academic |
| Amanda Oleis | Forward | NJCAA Distinguished Academic | |
| 2006 | Elyse Lovelace | Forward | NJCAA honorable mention |
| 2005 | Gena Gutierrez | Midfielder | NJCAA Distinguished Academic |
| Lauren Dabbs | Defender | NJCAA Academic | |
| Jana Malavasi | Goalkeeper | NJCAA Academic | |
| Kristen Mattei | Defender | NJCAA Distinguished Academic | |
| Matthew Peterson | Midfielder | NJCAA Academic | |
| Alyssa Robson | Midfielder | NJCAA Distinguished Academic | |
| Robby Tucker | Midfielder | NJCAA Distinguished Academic | |
| 2004 | Gena Gutierrez | Midfielder | NJCAA honorable mention |
| 2003 | Jon Fortenberry | Midfielder | NJCAA Distinguished Academic |
| Megan Jackson | Forward | NJCAA Distinguished Academic | |
| Tommy Robison | Forward | 2nd team NJCAA | |
| 2002 | Amy Dominguez | Forward | NJCAA Academic |
| Amanda Nieves | Forward | NJCAA Academic | |
| Tommy Robison | Forward | 2nd team NJCAA | |
| Jenny Vinzetta | Midfielder | NJCAA Academic | |
| Jon Woolfolk | Defender | NJCAA Academic |